"We just want to be that neighborhood place."
Balt Depina said that to What Now Atlanta in September. He was describing why The Lunch Counter, a smash-burger shop known for takeout, is giving up its Thompson Bridge Road counter for a sit-down dining room on Main Street. His line fits more than one restaurant this fall. Most of what's headed to downtown Gainesville through early 2027 isn't new to town. It comes from operators who already feed Hall County from a food truck, a side street or a Flowery Branch storefront, and they're now moving closer to the Square. One of them, Roland Stanley, is behind two of the four biggest openings.
The Shortest Moves on the List
Start with the two relocations, since they show the pattern most clearly.
Nina B started The Lunch Counter as a catering food truck in 2021. Next came a takeout-only shop on Thompson Bridge Road. Its new home at 893 Main St. SW grows the space from 1,200 to 2,500 square feet and adds what regulars kept asking for, which was a place to sit down. The burgers, subs and loaded fries will stay on the menu, and the bigger kitchen leaves room for a few new dishes. Depina called it "a great new chapter, not too far from the current location." The target is November. WGTJ picked up the story on September 19 and reported that the move probably won't happen "until November."
Decoy's move is shorter in distance and bigger in profile. The eatery, bar and game spot opened at 123 Green St. NE, and its menu runs from short ribs and fried chicken to fish tacos. In July, owner Rand Carswell announced a move to 104 Main St. on the Square itself, with a new concept that combines food, cocktails and games. AccessNorthGA reported that he expects the new space to open in early 2027 and that Green Street will stay open until then. So nobody loses a Decoy night while the build-out happens.
In both cases, a business that already has regulars is trading a working location for one closer to the Square's foot traffic. They aren't arriving from somewhere else.
A Flowery Branch Brunch Spot Learns Dinner
Caroline's All Day comes from a little farther away, but it's still local. It's a Gainesville offshoot of Caroline's on Main in Flowery Branch, a brunch spot known for avocado toast and buttermilk pancakes. The Gainesville version moves past that daytime format by adding lunch and dinner, and it will have a private dining room for events. The team is targeting an October or November opening at 400 Jesse Jewell Parkway.
That address has history. Standard Service, a restaurant and taproom with 60 self-serve taps and TVs for watching games, opened there in late spring 2022 and closed at the end of May 2026. Before that, the building was a gas station. Hoodline's write-up of the opening pulls that history together. The new look is the opposite of a service station. A Gainesville Times photo caption describes light wood, gold picture frames and pastel-pink decor.
The partners are Roland Stanley, chef Nick St. Clair and Gustavo Godinez Jr. of Big Burritos. Stanley's name shows up again on Grove Street.
The Restaurateur Who Started Inside Main Street Market
If you've eaten on the Square in the last few years, you've probably eaten at one of Roland Stanley's places. He is the sole owner of The Stag Chophouse at 110 Main Street SW and a partner in Peyton's Pie Company. Peyton's sits at 118 Main St. SW, Suite E, inside Main Street Market. That same market is where he started. In 2020, the Gainesville Times covered the opening of Cork It in Main Street Market and reported that 150 people came to the opening-day event. In 2023, Stanley and his partner Jim Tortorelli turned chopBLOCK Chophouse and Club into The Stag.
Anaba Sushi is his most ambitious downtown project yet. It's an omakase restaurant with craft cocktails at 610 Grove Street, led by chef Jason Vullo with Stanley backing it. The plan for the roughly 1,200-square-foot space includes two bars, one of them a sushi bar, plus an outdoor area. When the Gainesville Times first reported the concept on May 1, 2026, it said the team had Michelin-star ambitions and expected to open in about three months. That would have meant late summer. City building inspection records show a renovation permit opened on July 27, 2026, with an estimated value of $75,000 to alter 900 square feet of existing restaurant space. By mid-September, Stanley was posting on Facebook that Anaba was "getting very close," still with no date.
Vullo's background is regional too. Atlanta Magazine reports that he was named to the 2024 class of Georgia Grown Executive Chefs while running the kitchen at Community Brew and Tap in Cornelia.
Add it up and two of the four fall openings come from a partner group whose Gainesville history began in a market hall on the Square.
Where Each Opening Stands as of October 3
None of these four has publicly confirmed an opening date yet. Here's the latest from each, in the order they're expected:
- Anaba Sushi, 610 Grove St. The May forecast was about three months. The latest word, from September, is "getting very close," with no date announced.
- Caroline's All Day, 400 Jesse Jewell Pkwy. Targeting October or November, as of the most recent reports in mid-September.
- The Lunch Counter, 893 Main St. SW. Targeting November. The Thompson Bridge Road shop remains its current home until the move.
- Decoy, 104 Main St. Expected in early 2027, with 123 Green St. NE open in the meantime.
Before you plan a night around any of these, check the restaurant's own social pages. A target month is a builder's estimate, and Anaba's has already moved once.
The changes away from the Square are smaller. Farmhouse Coffee announced a second Gainesville location inside Elevation Fitness at 1210 Thompson Bridge Road, but hasn't given an opening date. Papa's Pizza To Go at 658 Dawsonville Highway has closed for good, according to the Gainesville Times in August.
Why the Square Keeps Pulling Them In
The city has made its own case for this pull. Lakeside News reported in March that the city has named the area around the Square the "Downtown Dining District." Tourism director Robyn Lynch put it plainly: "Downtown has become a locally owned dining destination." The same article lists recent arrivals like Baddies Burger House on Washington Street, CHRSTEAK on Bradford Street and Sanctuary on the Square, and names other places on or near the Square, including Cotto, Consuelo and Recess Southern Gastro-pub.
There are also practical rules behind the district. According to the city's Explore Gainesville vendor page, customers of alcohol-licensed businesses inside the district can carry a drink onto public property, including parks and sidewalks, between noon and midnight. The drink has to be in a clear plastic cup of up to 16 ounces, and you can take out no more than two at a time. Private property isn't covered, so each owner decides for their own space. That page was posted in 2025, so confirm with the city that the rules haven't changed before you count on them for a night out.
Main Street is where most of this is landing. The Stag is at 110, Peyton's at 118, Decoy is headed to 104, and The Lunch Counter is moving to 893 Main St. SW.
If a short walk to dinner on the Square is part of how you picture your next chapter, or you'd like to know which streets put Anaba, Caroline's and The Stag within an easy stroll, Jennifer Anderson would love to walk Gainesville with you. Let's Connect. Start Your Georgia Home Story.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.